How Often You Should Review Your Scorecards

Notepad with magnifying glass and pencil

With scorecards taking time to define, it can be tempting to take a ‘one-and-done’ approach. However, doing so can put you at risk of not only using outdated line items, but skewing your QA to outdated concepts.

Why Should You Review Your Scorecards?

Having data from regular evaluations enables your team leaders and managers to build a profile of individual team members, but also the overall team. Analyzing this information can reveal trends and patterns, which in turn enables you to take action quickly to resolve any issues.

For example, if a majority of the team is performing poorly in compliance, then additional team training should be on the cards to improve the issue.

But before doing that, it’s worth asking whether it’s the agents, or the scorecard itself. If the phrasing, angle or criteria of the scorecard isn’t quite fit for purpose or the channel it’s designed for, then you’ve got an entirely different issue.

This is why it’s so important to review scorecards. They’re an essential aid to not only measuring and improving performance, but also preventing bad practices spreading through a contact centre.

It’s challenging, but by following a quality framework and reviewing often, you stand a much better chance at success.

How Often You Should Review Your Scorecards

Ideally, you should review your scorecards at least every six months. We recommend this timeframe because it allows you to:

  • Collect enough data to identify patterns and anomalies
  • Stress-test the scorecard’s criteria
  • Factor in any regulation/compliance changes (if relevant)

At the same time, six months comes around fast in a contact centre! Before you know it, you’ll be into a regular rhythm of reviewing that means you can roll out meaningful changes that help your team and business collate more accurate, useful data.

Evaluating Your Scorecards

To evaluate your scorecard, ask the following questions:

1. Is It Working and Meeting Requirements?

Is your scorecard easily understood and applicable to the types of conversations your agents are having? Are the scoring criteria in place providing genuinely useful insights as well as addressing necessities?

If you’re struggling to come to a conclusion, it’s a good idea to loop in your evaluators for feedback. They’re in the perfect position to outline areas for improvement or where confusion typically arises.

Calibration sessions can also help shine a light on whether scoring criteria are too open to interpretation, so you’ll get more consistent evaluations across the board.

2. Has It Adapted to Your Changing Business?

Have you adopted new channels? Adapted to updated regulations? If so, does your scorecard reflect this?

This question is more about checking nothing crucial has been missed off, keeping your business accountable.

3. Is It Helping to Improve Quality?

Ultimately, the whole point of using scorecards is to improve agent and overall team performance over time.

For example, are you putting actions in place to develop and motivate your team – like training and coaching – in response to both high and low scores?

It’s worth assessing this at both an individual and team level to identify whether the scorecard is helping you make improvements, and at what scale.


Scorecard evaluations don’t need to take a long time, but naturally they may take longer if you identify issues. If you’re making changes or suggesting a new version, it’s a good idea to involve your agents, evaluators and team leaders

This blog post has been re-published by kind permission of EvaluAgent – View the Original Article

For more information about EvaluAgent - visit the EvaluAgent Website

About EvaluAgent

EvaluAgent EvaluAgent provide software and services that help contact centres engage and motivate their staff to deliver great customer experiences.

Find out more about EvaluAgent

Call Centre Helper is not responsible for the content of these guest blog posts. The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author, and do not necessarily reflect those of Call Centre Helper.

Author: EvaluAgent

Published On: 4th Apr 2024 - Last modified: 9th Apr 2024
Read more about - Industry Insights, , ,

Follow Us on LinkedIn

Recommended Articles

question exclamation
Evaluation Spreadsheets vs. Scorecards. Which One to Choose?
A photo of a performance review
25 Performance Review Phrases for Customer Service
A Scorecard with gold items
7 Tips to Build Effective Quality Assurance Scorecards
golf scorecard
How BPOs can use Scorecards for Better Coaching