Why Coaching Still Requires the Human Touch

Coaching is undoubtedly entering a new era, one where AI can highlight patterns, surface risks, and suggest next steps.

Yet it cannot (and arguably, should not) replace the meaningful coaching conversations that still rely on empathy, curiosity, and human judgement.

That’s why we asked our consultants panel how important it really is for leaders to ultimately preserve the connection that turns feedback into growth, as well as their best advice on ensuring AI is only used to strengthen (rather than dilute) the human touch.

…Because Shared Call Listening Is Still a Valuable Learning Exercise

Elaine Lee, Managing Director and Consultant, Reynolds Busby Lee Limited — Elaine Lee

The strongest coaches treat data as a starting point, not a conclusion. Metrics and QA scorecards can highlight patterns and prompt focus, but they should never replace human judgement. Human-centric coaching starts with preparation.

That means listening to the call, or reviewing an email or live chat conversation in advance, reviewing the QA feedback, and arriving at the coaching session clear on what you want to explore – rather than winging the session and reacting in the moment.

One of the most effective habits I see is coaches then listening to the call again, this time with the agent.

Shared listening creates shared understanding. Instead of delivering an assessment, the coach can invite reflection with a simple “Help me to understand what was happening for you here.” The conversation becomes exploratory rather than evaluative, and learning happens faster.

Used well, technology should create space for better conversations, not replace them. When tools support preparation and reduce admin, coaching sessions can slow down and become more reflective.

Contributed by: Elaine Lee, Managing Director and Consultant, Reynolds Busby Lee Limited

…Because Presence, Attention, and Conversation Are Still Where Coaching Will Do Its Best Work

Technology can absolutely support good coaching! When it’s used well, it creates clarity, consistency, and helpful insight. It can help to surface patterns and remove some of the admin, and therefore frees up time.

However, coaches who create the strongest connections tend to be a bit more thoughtful about how and when these tools are used, so they end up supporting the conversation rather than taking over.

Presence, attention, and conversation are still where coaching will do its best work!

Human-centric coaching shows up in small, deliberate choices:

It’ll looks like preparing with data beforehand so coaching time is focused on the person rather than a screen.
It’ll sounds like naming what we notice in someone’s tone or energy, not just their numbers.
It’ll feel like allowing pauses instead of rushing to solutions and listening for what might be sitting underneath performance conversations.

Technology should help us show up more human, not less. When human intelligence stays front and centre, coaching remains meaningful, effective, and deeply connected.

Contributed by: Emma Lloyd, Experience Director, Create the Ripple Ltd

…Because Coaching Isn’t Just About What’s Said – It’s Also About What’s Left Unsaid

The skill of a coach lies in picking up on subtle cues that technology can’t – a shift in tone, a hesitation in answering or a change in body language.

These moments often reveal how someone is really feeling and can allow the coach to adapt their approach in real time.

Noticing and responding to these nuances builds trust and psychological safety, creating the environment for honest, reflective and meaningful conversations.

In an increasingly digital world, emotional intelligence and compassion are our superpowers; technology can support the process, but human connection remains the differentiator – just like this:

Start with a check-in to understand mindset and help tailor your approach
Use silence and pauses to give space for reflection
Listen for changes in tone, pace or volume, not just the words
Gently share what you observe: “I noticed you paused there…”
Mirror language and emotion to show understanding
Use encouragement and reinforce capability to build confidence
Ask reflective questions such as “How did that feel for you?” or “What did you notice in that moment?”
Stay curious rather than jump to conclusions

Contributed by: Gemma Carter-Morris, Managing Director at Next Steps Consulting

…Because a Coach’s Role Is Still to Translate Data Into Encouragement and Actionable Insights

The best coaches recognize that while dashboards and performance metrics provide clarity, they are only meaningful when paired with empathy, curiosity, and genuine dialogue.

Human-centric coaching begins with mindset. Active listening – pausing, paraphrasing, and acknowledging emotions – creates psychological safety, allowing agents to share challenges honestly.

Compassion, expressed through tone and body language, reinforces that coaching is not about correction but about growth.

Technology, when used wisely, becomes a supportive backdrop. Tools can highlight trends or flag opportunities, but the coach’s role is to translate data into encouragement and actionable insights.

For example, rather than focusing solely on numbers, a coach might use analytics to celebrate small wins or uncover hidden strengths. This balance ensures agents feel empowered rather than monitored.

Contributed by: Molly Naidoo, Managing Director, Telecommunications Sales Mastery Academy

If you want ideas for how to develop empathy in your contact centre leaders, read our article: How to Limit Agent Burnout With Empathy-Led Leadership

…Because If You Always Outsource Your Thinking, You’ll Lose Your Edge

Vicky Hampson founder of Victorious Consulting and Loveson — Vicky Hampson

When you bypass the human element, you aren’t just saving time – you’re allowing your most valuable capabilities to waste away.

By prioritizing human-first coaching, leaders build the behavioural “muscle” required to:

Simplify the Chaos – Distil a complex challenge into a clear, solvable problem.
Define the “End-in-Mind” – Stop reacting to the “now” and start architecting the outcome.
Audit the Self – Build the deep self-awareness and accountability that no algorithm can replicate.
Master the Reframe – Adopt different lenses to see the “unseen” opportunities.

AI can feed us information in seconds. It is seductive. But in our “always-on” world, failing to adopt a human-first approach makes precious thinking time redundant. If you always outsource your thinking, you’ll lose your edge!

Contributed by: Vicky Hampson, Founder, Victorious Consulting

★★★★★