New research from Five9 has found that just 13% of UK consumers who recently contacted financial services providers believe AI should handle charge disputes without human involvement.
Andy Dignan, President, Five9, comments: “The question for banks isn’t whether AI belongs in customer service, but where it should be allowed to act alone. Customers may be comfortable with AI answering a straightforward account enquiry, but a disputed charge or sensitive financial issue demands a different level of care.
“Financial institutions should be measuring success by more than the number of interactions they can automate. The real opportunity is to use AI to make routine service faster and more effective, while ensuring human judgement and accountability remain central when the stakes are higher.”
The study, involving 413 UK consumers who had contacted financial services customer service teams in the previous six months, found that 51% want charge disputes handled entirely by a person, while 37% would accept AI involvement with human oversight.
The findings also revealed that 91% expect human involvement in high-stakes escalations, 86% in refunds or financial adjustments, and 85% in sensitive identity verification.
However, consumers appear more comfortable with AI handling routine enquiries, with 77% supporting its involvement in order or account status updates, including 35% who would allow AI to manage these independently.
The research highlights differing levels of consumer acceptance of AI in financial services, with greater demand for human oversight when interactions involve sensitive information or financial decisions.
Author: Robyn Coppell
Reviewed by: Jo Robinson