Is AI Factored Into Your ESG Strategy Yet?

ESG Environmental, Social, and Governance concept with ESG on digital button

AI is rapidly becoming a board-level priority, but the rush to adopt new technology is also exposing some uncomfortable gaps in Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) that can’t be ignored.

So, where are these gaps and what steps should CX leaders take to close them? We spoke to Brian Manusama to find out.

Why Is AI Having Such an Impact on the ESG Agenda?

AI is shaking up what ESG means across all 3 pillars – from the Environmental impact of call summarization, voicebots, and real-time transcription relying on servers that consume energy, to the Social issues of managing people with AI tools, as well as fresh challenges around accessibility and customer vulnerability, right through to evolving Governance around who makes decisions about AI and who is ultimately accountable.

What Steps Should CX Leaders Take to Close the Gap?

With so much to navigate, it can be difficult to know where to start – so here are 4 key areas to focus on to help you adapt and keep your ESG agenda on track:

1. Understand What Is Happening Across the Regulatory Landscape

AI governance is becoming both a regulatory issue and a procurement consideration. The challenge is keeping track of the different requirements while ensuring AI governance does not become something that is only addressed once a new regulation comes into force.

For example, the EU AI Act is already being enforced, including transparency rules around labelling AI-generated content and disclosing when customers are interacting with a bot rather than a person.

However, it’s important to also be aware that the different requirements are coming into force at different stages, and that the heavier obligations covering high-risk standalone AI systems (where a lot of contact centre AI sits) have been pushed back to December 2027.

There is also an emerging international standard to consider – ISO 42001. This is an AI management system standard, broadly comparable to ISO 27001 for information security.

Contact centre technology vendors are increasingly seeking certification against such standards as enterprise customers begin to make them part of procurement requirements.

Of course, this is just a snapshot in time, but it shows just how much is happening in the regulatory space and how important it is that leaders tune into what’s changing and when.

2. Rethink What Wellbeing and Autonomy Look Like for Your Frontline

Leaders also need to tune into the unforeseen impact of using AI to manage their workforce.

AI-driven scheduling, real-time coaching nudges, sentiment scoring, and other monitoring tools are presented as productivity improvements – but their impact often goes beyond efficiency.

When technology influences how agents are scheduled, monitored, coached or assessed, it becomes an employee experience and ESG issue too.

The result? A fundamental contradiction for organizations that publicly commit to employee wellbeing, whilst simultaneously introducing AI systems that affect agents without sufficient scrutiny.

Brian Manusama, Analyst and Executive Partner at Actionary
Brian Manusama

“You cannot put employee wellbeing proudly into your ESG report on one hand and then deploy an unaudited AI scoring model on your agents on the other! And this is not a hypothetical tension.

This is already happening in real organizations right now and it’s starting to get noticed by employees, by journalists, but now also by the regulator.

This is particularly important as younger workers form an increasingly significant proportion of the workforce – with research suggesting that there is little tolerance among this generation for being managed by an opaque “black box”.

If they do not understand how an AI system is assessing or managing them, they may simply choose to leave – and potentially even share their decision publicly.” – Brian Manusama

It’s also worth noting that there is growing evidence from organizations deploying AI monitoring that the introduction of these tools can coincide with increased agent attrition.

Therefore AI-driven workforce management cannot simply be assessed according to its productivity gains. Its impact on wellbeing, autonomy, and trust also needs to be considered.

3. Close the AI Governance Gap at Board Level

Make sure your governance is keeping pace with ambition too! AI has become a major board priority and a significant area of planned investment. However, research points to a considerable gap between the enthusiasm for AI and the mechanisms in place to oversee it.

Around two-thirds of directors are reportedly using AI for board work, while only around one-fifth of boards have a documented AI governance policy.

All of which creates a potentially significant problem – as AI may be moving rapidly through an organization without anyone having clear accountability for deciding how it should be used, what risks are acceptable, and how those risks should be monitored.

And the problem becomes particularly apparent when organizations try to identify who actually owns AI governance.

“Only a minority of the world’s largest companies have an explicit oversight mechanism at board level at all. So that gap of ambition without oversight is exactly where the reputational and the regulatory risk really lives.” – Brian Manusama

For CX leaders, this means AI governance cannot sit solely within the technology function. There needs to be clarity around ownership, oversight, and accountability – particularly where AI is influencing customer interactions and agent attrition.

4. Address the Shadow AI “Blind Spot”

And it’s not just a board-level challenge. While senior leaders may be developing formal AI strategies, frontline agents are already using AI tools in their day-to-day work, and whilst some of that activity may be approved, some may not!

This is a very real challenge known as shadow AI that sits directly at the intersection of technology, governance, and employee behaviour – and is a particular concern for contact centres, where the frontline has access to sensitive customer information and may be tempted to paste transcripts or other content into personal AI tools to help generate responses or solve problems, ultimately creating a data protection and governance blind spot.

Yet the issue is also difficult to solve simply by banning AI. If agents are already finding AI useful, removing access to it without providing a practical alternative could simply push the activity further underground.

Therefore, success often comes down to making approved alternatives easier and faster to use than the unofficial ones.

★★★★★

Leaders Cannot Ignore That AI Is Now Part of the ESG Conversation

Above all, what’s clear is that AI should increasingly be viewed as part of the wider ESG agenda – rather than as a separate technology exercise.

For CX leaders, this means keeping a close eye on everything from how regulations are changing and impacting procurement decisions to what shadow AI looks like on the frontline.

After all, the technology may be moving quickly, but responsible adoption requires organizations to move just as fast – if not faster.  

If you are looking for more information on contact centre governance, read these articles next:

Author
Megan Jones

Megan Jones, Editor, Call Centre Helper

Megan interviews inspiring people across the contact centre industry to capture these amazing voices and turn them into best practice articles – covering all elements of what it takes to deliver truly outstanding employee and customer experiences.

Connect with Megan on LinkedIn

Read more by Megan Jones

Reviewed by: Jo Robinson

Contributions From:

Brian Manusama
Register for our webinar.